Wednesday, February 8, 2012


 by Ray Ferris
author of the book “The Art of Child Protection.”
You can purchase it from him by writing to

Ray Ferris receiving the Justice Award
As I have stated before, there is no shortage of experts who can define autism, bipolar disorder, attention deficit disorder, hyperactivity and on and on. There is no shortage of experts who can tell us confidently just what we should be doing with all these children and others and how much more of it we should be doing. There is just one little snag. There is a great shortage of results. If we look at the long haul, most autistic children are unable to manage independently as adults. We can spend all kinds of money on them and we can demand all sorts of things from the government, but for the most part we are describing process. Certainly all the people who work with autism and other difficult conditions are dedicated and sincere and they will usually see small gains here and there, because they must believe in what they are doing. However, most of these children will not be functioning normally by any stretch of the imagination even after years of effort.

Of course there are a few notable exceptions like Ms. Temple Grandin, who is a genius with animals, but they are few and far between. What do we really hope to accomplish with children like Ayn in a regular school setting. It takes two full time teaching assistants to manage her behaviour. Not only is she not getting an education, but she is probably a distraction for other children. Albert Einstein pointed out that it is irrational to do the same thing over and over again and expect the results to be different. He could have said stupid. He was thinking in the scientific context, but the same is true for society at large. Just as the biggest countries in the world cannot borrow their way out of debt, but they keep trying. The children’s ministry cannot solve non-administrative problems with administrative devices, but that is all they ever do. Freudian psychology claimed that people’s maladjustment could be fixed by the process of psycho-analysis. If it did not seem to be working, then there should be more of it. More sessions over more years. Never would they admit that the theory could be flawed. It was flawed of course, but two generations wasted their money on it before it was abandoned by the insurance companies.

With all the money that is spent on autistic programs, can the authorities define specific goals and targets that they hope to reach? If they can, I would like to hear about them, because all I see everywhere is couched in generalities. In school we expect children to learn to read and write, to do arithmetic and to learn about the world of science and humanity. Children who cannot learn to read and write cannot participate in many important ways. Do such children really belong in a normal classroom situation? If all we can hope to do is to contain and manage behaviour, should we be doing this at the expense of other children. Many types of children, such as those with Down syndrome, can be trained and they can learn to manage their own behaviour. But many autistic children cannot. What are we hoping to do with them? Can anyone enlighten me?

Later this week, I hope to write about the function of the protection system with special needs children. When is it appropriate for the state to take over parenting for them and when it is not? Ray Ferris

Ray Ferris is an occasional GPS post writer. Retired now, Ray speaks from 31 years in child welfare and protection as a social worker, district supervisor and family court coordinator. He cannot tolerate injustice imposed upon families by ineffectual case work.

Ron's Twitter


  1. The sad thing is that not everything can be "fixed." Some things just ARE.

  2. For Ray Ferris, Ray, the Temple Grandin website is very informative. She is a PhD after all and she answers many questions. Here is one.

    QUESTION: Dr. Grandin, if you could give only one piece of advice to teachers and one piece of advice to parents, what would that be? -- Christa

    ANSWER: The advice I would give to teachers and/or parents would be to develop the child’s strengths and teach them from those. For instance, if a child likes art, then teach with art. If they like trains, then teach with trains, dinosaurs, etc. You can teach Math with trains, you can teach Art with trains. And so forth.

    It also helps the child to develop their interest further by broadening it out. They can learn history from studying parts of the world where dinosaurs once lived. An interesting fact is dinosaurs once lived at the Denver Airport! -- Temple

  3. It makes me sad to think how strongly "we" support integration. If most people only knew what integration actually looked like on a day to day basis.
    I work in a new learning centre, designed for children/youth who have been diagnosed with ASD, FASD, and several other exceptionalities. They spend the day in a sensory-sensitive environment, working on their school work, learning life skills, social skills and behavior challenges.
    I have one student that spent most of his day in a janitors closet doing his school work. Even then, the school work he brought home was scribed for him, There was no evidence that this child was actually learning anything and you can be certain he wasn't being treated equally by his peers.
    I have worked with him now for 13 months and he writes all his own work, he reads out loud to me everyday and he interacts with other kids his age every day! He has excelled beyond what we even had originally imagined.
    My 14 year old son also attends this learning centre and he has grown so much in the past year and I love that he has the chance to learn, and grow in an environment that considers his interests, works with him when things are challenging and doesn't leave him working alone in a janitors closet!
    Thanks so much,

    1. This would be a good idea. Improve education for kids with adhd and autism. i think autism is becoming easier to diagnose so there's going to be an increase in people diagnosed with autism.


I encourage your comments using this filter.
1. Write politely with a sincere statement, valid question, justifiable comment.
2. Engage with the blog post or a previous comment whether you agree or disagree.
3. Avoid hate, profanity, name calling, character attack, slander and threats, particularly when using specific names.
4. Do not advertise