CONGRATS FIFTH ESTATE - WELL DONE SBS DOCUMENTARY

I waited, I watched, I am Pleased

You should check this link to see when the show is repeated. It will also be archived at the CBC TV site. (Repeat airtimes)

DIAGNOSIS MURDER

This long awaited documentary was better than I had hoped! This has been the most significant public awareness vehicle to date, to alert Canada to the possibilities of unjust allegations and convictions with regard to Shaken Baby Syndrome.

The Fifth Estate investigative team, the production crew, and Gillian Findlay are a class act. They researched both sides of this controversial issue and they allowed both sides to speak. Yet it was clear enough on which side of the diagnostic/judicial conundrum Fifth Estate stood.

Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS) is a medical diagnosis based on the presence of a diagnostic triad: (1) retinal bleeding, (2) bleeding in the protective layer of the brain, and (3) brain swelling. During the past twenty years this has been the preferred diagnosis. It was formulaic. These injuries in a child were considered conclusive evidence of a shaken baby. Every shaken baby has a shaker. A shaker has committed a criminal offence punishable upon conviction.  But WAIT!

In Toronto, one of Jeffrey Smith’s twin daughters, born very prematurely and struggling to live in their early months, died while in his sole care one day eighteen years ago. He went to prison after being tried for murder but sentenced for manslaughter. This was one of two heart-wrenching stories featured last night. Recently he was exonerated.That little girl died of natural causes. Jeff's life has changed forever. His other daughter is eighteen years of age now and he has never seen her. She was raised by her mom who although she was not present when the little girl died, was convinced by the police that the father was responsible. She did not appear on air.

Zabeth and Paul Bayne of Surrey, BC, had charges dropped in 2007 but their three children were removed from them because of suspicion that one of them had injured their youngest child. She did not die. She was gravely ill for a long while. She too had been born with some prematurity but in a household accident at seven weeks of age she had also been struck by a sibling as he fell on her while running. That explanation did not wash with authorities, both law enforcement and medical. A pediatrician diagnosed her as a ‘Shaken Baby.’ RCMP dropped initial charges due to insufficient evidence but the Ministry of Children understandably continued to consider the parents a risk. Not understandable was the Ministry’s unwillingness to ask for a second opinion - a disinclination to entertain the possibility there may be another explanation for her injuries. It took four (4) years and everything that this determined couple could give in order to win a verdict that they were not responsible for the child’s injuries and to have their children returned to them this past year, four years after the saga began.

Fifth Estate considerately, wisely held off the broadcast of this show until the Bayne family was no longer under the review period assigned for the first three months that the children were back with their parents. The Baynes were not vindictive in the interview. They plainly expressed how the ordeal had affected them personally and how helpless they had been within a child protection system that assumes guilt until proven innocent. Last night’s show may become a resource to prevent other innocent and grieving parents from being presumed guilty.

THE FIFTH ESTATE SHAKEN BABY FEATURE TONIGHT

When to Watch

Tonight, Friday at 9 p.m. JAN 13

9:30 p.m. in Newfoundland & Labrador (Repeat airtimes)

DIAGNOSIS MURDER

For decades, the diagnosis of shaken baby syndrome virtually guaranteed convictions, shattering the lives of thousands of parents, babysitters and families. Now new evidence questions whether the syndrome even exists, and whether some have been wrongfully convicted.

In a promotional video of an interview this subject is discussed for five minutes – good introduction. Paul and Zabeth Bayne are interviewed.

CBC News: 'Shaken Baby Syndrome?'

Reporter Gillian Findlay sits down with CBC News Network's Heather Hiscox. In the interview, they discuss research that suggests that the widely accepted shaken baby syndrome may actually be a physical impossibility. http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/2011-2012/diagnosismurder/news.html

If you are not in Canada and cannot tune in tonight, the video will be archived online for viewing around the world. And the link will be placed at this blog site.

Gillian Findlay hosts and reports for CBC Television's investigative program, the fifth estate, and she is the principal reporter tonight with video and interviews that have been researched and assembled for many months for tonight awaited feature. Here is her bio. Her colleagues are

Bob McKeown and Linden MacIntyre

 I AM CERTAIN THAT IT IS MERELY COINCIDENCE THAT THIS BROADCAST AIRS ON FRIDAY THE 13TH, ON ONE OF THE DARKEST STORIES OF OUR SOCIETY, WRONGLY ACCCUSED PARENTS AND CAREGIVERS. 

Diagnosis Murder

SCRIPT TAKEN DIRECTLY FROM THE CBC FIFTH ESTATE SITE.

"It's a scenario as horrifying as it is heartbreaking: a frustrated parent ... a baby that just won't stop crying ... and suddenly, what were tender, cradling arms become instruments of death. At least this is how Shaken Baby Syndrome has been characterized in countless court cases in recent years. But what are the scientific foundations of this diagnosis?

Gillian Findlay examines the conventional wisdom around Shaken Baby Syndrome, discovering that those who question it often feel targeted by those who believe passionately in it.  And yet new science suggests the so-called syndrome may be a physical impossibility.

"Diagnosis Murder" tells the story of several Canadian parents who say they were wrongfully accused--and the leading-edge medical researchers who believe they're telling the truth. The stakes are high: Some have gone to jail. All have had their other children taken away from them.

One couple recently had their children returned after a four-year battle. Even though the courts in B.C. cleared Zabeth and Paul Baynes of charges they had shaken their baby, the couple feel they will carry the stigma for life. Another man in Ontario has now had his case put up for judicial review, giving him hope that his name may too be cleared.

Is Shaken Baby Syndrome conclusive evidence of murder? Or is it a scientific hypothesis that has convicted an untold number of parents as killers -- when their children actually died from other causes?"